Dealing with the abuse of data protection rights


Lessons from a recent case before the LAG Schleswig-Holstein (judgment of 21.2.2023 - 1 Sa 148/22)

In the world of data protection, privacy rights are a cornerstone of personal data protection. However, it is no secret that these rights can sometimes be abused for purposes other than their intended use. In this article, we would like to highlight a recent case in Germany and provide valuable insights on how to effectively deal with the abuse of data protection rights.

Our story begins with a rejected applicant who took an unconventional route after being rejected. This case, which was heard by the LAG Schleswig-Holstein (judgment of 21.2.2023 - 1 Sa 148/22), offers crucial lessons for those dealing with the complexities of data protection.

Abuse of data protection rights
In this specific case, which was heard by the LAG Schleswig-Holstein (judgment of 21.2.2023 - 1 Sa 148/22), the plaintiff applied for a job and was subsequently rejected. After the rejection, the applicant demanded €1,500 and threatened to sue for age discrimination (Art. 15 para. 2 AGG). When the company offered him an interview, he declined and later invoked data protection rights (Art. 15 GDPR). The court ruled against the plaintiff and found that the action constituted an abuse of rights. The plaintiff was seen to be using data protection law mainly to put pressure on the defendant to obtain compensation. The court considered this to be a case of abuse of rights where the statutory right was used for hidden or unfair purposes.

Expert advice:
Here are the most important findings:

Staying true to the original purpose of data protection: It is crucial to use data protection laws for their original purpose - to protect privacy. Be aware of potential abuse scenarios and prepare to counter them.

Ethics and vigilance: Maintain ethical standards in all your data protection efforts. Encourage your organization to prioritize data privacy for the right reasons, without using it as a tool for financial gain or pressure.

Education and awareness: Educate your team on the essence of data protection laws. Knowledge is often the best defense against potential abuse.

In conclusion, this recent case from Germany is a stark reminder that while data protection rights are essential, they should always be exercised with integrity and a genuine commitment to privacy. We stand by your side to uphold these principles and ensure that your privacy remains protected and your reputation untarnished.

Share this post :